Sweet Cream Coffee Caramel Ice Cream
Sweet cream and dark coffee ice creams swirled together with a coffee scented caramel sauce. This Sweet Cream Coffee Caramel Ice Cream is absolutely irresistible. This easy ice cream recipe is low carb, keto, gluten-free, grain-free, sugar-free, and Trim Healthy Mama friendly.
My sweet husband brought home no less than 5 pints of Haagen Dazs ice cream a few weeks ago. He got one for each kid and one for us. I was like, “uhhh… thanks honey….”
I wasn’t planning on eating any of it since it is definitely not on plan for Trim Healthy Mama. But after a long day, I decided to just ‘try’ the Sweet Cream Coffee Caramel. The night I only had a few bites. But then the next night I had a few more. And before I knew it the pint was gone.
Which is why I don’t buy ice cream when I’m the one who goes grocery shopping. I know my weaknesses and limitations. Certain junk food can be in the house without tempting me. But pints of high-quality ice cream in favorite flavors? Nope.
I just had to make a healthier version of that sweet cream and coffee caramel ice cream. The sweet cream base was easy, it’s just my vanilla ice cream but without the vanilla. The coffee part was a little trickier because I wanted to be able to make coffee ice cream from the sweet cream ice cream without needing to refreeze the ice cream machine bowl. Adding in a paste made from instant coffee did the trick!
My favorite part of this ice cream is that the caramel stays soft and chewy even after a few days in the freezer. I was afraid it would harden like a praline or toffee but nope. Soft and chewy. It’s tempting to just dig all the caramel out and eat it plain. The caramel does crystallize a little bit. That is just the nature of sugar alcohols and I don’t know of any way around it. It didn’t bother me or stop us from eating all the coffee caramel ice cream.
Sweet Cream Coffee Caramel Ice Cream Necessities:
Caramel Sauce Ingredients: butter, heavy cream, sweetener, salt, instant coffee
Ice Cream Base Ingredients: heavy cream, unsweetened almond milk, sweetener, egg yolks***, glycerin (*** If you are concerned about using raw egg yolks you can purchase pasteurized eggs or you can temper the ice cream base.)
Coffee Paste Ingredients: instant coffee, water
What ice cream machine should I buy?
I have an old faithful Cuisinart Ice Cream Machine that has been faithful for over 10 years. It is worth the investment to be able to control the ingredients in your ice cream and be able to whip up any flavor you can imagine!
How to Make Sweet Cream Coffee Caramel Ice Cream
First, you will be making the caramel. Next, put the ingredients for the ice cream base in a blender. Blend until smooth. Pour into an ice cream machine and churn according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
Meanwhile, make the coffee paste. When the ice cream looks done spoon half of it into the pan you will freeze it in. I used two loaf pans. Put in the freezer. Add the coffee paste to the remaining ice cream and churn for an additional five minutes.
Remove the pans from the freezer. Spoon the coffee ice cream on. Gently swirl the two ice cream flavors together. Take a butter knife and make a zigzag line down the center. This helps swirl in the caramel. Pour the caramel sauce into the crevasse. Gently swirl a little more. Put the pans back in the freezer until firm.
Like what you see? Follow me on Facebook! Love this recipe? Leave a comment & 5-star rating right here! Make sure you don’t miss new recipes by getting email updates!
Want to Save This Recipe?
Enter your email below & we'll send it to your inbox. Plus get great new recipes from us every week!
By submitting this form, you consent to receive emails from Joy Filled Eats
Sweet Cream Coffee Caramel Ice Cream
Equipment
Ingredients
Caramel Sauce Ingredients:
- 4 tbsp. butter
- 1/4 cup plus 2 tbsp heavy cream
- 3/4 cup Joy Filled Eats Sweetener (or see alternatives in recipe notes)
- 1/2 t. salt
- 1 tsp instant coffee
Ice Cream Base Ingredients:
- 2 cups heavy cream
- 1 1/2 cups unsweetened almond milk
- 1/2 cup Joy Filled Eats Sweetener (or see alternatives in recipe notes)
- 3 egg yolks ***
- 1 tbsp vegetable glycerin
Coffee Paste Ingredients:
- 1 tbsp instant coffee
- 1/2 - 1 tbsp water
Instructions
- First, you will be making the caramel. Combine 1/4 cup cream, 3 tbsp butter, and sweetener and cook over medium low heat. Stir frequently until bubbly, thickened, and lightly browned. Remove from the heat and add the salt, instant coffee, remaining 1 tbsp butter, and remaining 2 tbsp cream. Stir until smooth. Set aside and let cool to room temperature.
- Next, put the ingredients for the ice cream base in a blender. Blend until smooth. Pour into an ice cream machine and churn according to the manufacturer's instructions.
- Meanwhile, mix the 1 tbsp instant coffee with 1/2 tbsp water until a paste forms. You can add 1/2 tbsp more water if necessary.
- When the ice cream looks done spoon half of it into the pan you will freeze it in. I used two loaf pans. Put in the freezer. Add the coffee paste to the remaining ice cream and churn for an additional five minutes.
- Remove the pans from the freezer. Spoon the coffee ice on. Gently swirl the two ice cream flavors together. Take a butter knife and make a zigzag line down the center. This helps swirl in the caramel. Pour the caramel sauce into the crevasse. Gently swirl a little more. Put the pans back in the freezer until firm.
Notes
Nutrition
Originally Published on August 26, 2016. Revised and Republished on May 15, 2018.
I was wondering what could be subbed for instant coffee as I don’t have any and want to make this. I always have cold coffee in the fridge, could I use that instead?
That would be difficult because for this recipe half the ice cream is cream flavored and the other half has the coffee. If you want to make it all coffee you can sub brewed coffee for the almond milk.
Do you know how I could sub the sweetener for Monk Fruit? I have not been successful in using it in any desserts yet but I cannot have any sweetener with the stevia as I am allergic to it. This looks super yummy and has all my favorite flavors in it so cannot wait to try it.
I’m not certain monkfruit will work for the caramel, sorry. I’m sure it would be fine for the ice cream portion. You will need more, 1.5 to 2 times as much, if you are using a blend like lakanto. If you are using pure monkfruit extract you only use a tiny bit. I’m not sure of the ratio for that and that definitely cannot make caramel.
You indicate one batch is 12 servings, how much is one serving?
A serving is about 1/2 a cup.
Can you tell me how much sugar I should substitute for this recipe? And would that same ratio work in others of your recipes? I would like to try it because it sounds so delicious but I don’t use sugar type substitutes. Thank you.
Hi Jennie, you will need approximately twice as much. I have not tested this with sugar though. I’m not sure subbing would work in the caramel sauce. I would suggest looking for one that does call for sugar. As for my other recipes, it will depend on the recipe if sugar will work. But my sweetener is twice as sweet as sugar so you will always need more.
I may try doubling the amount of sugar as you suggest and see what happens. Thank you.
This looks delicious…if only I had an ice cream machine!
It was seriously the best $40 I’ve ever spent. It’s paid for itself over and over.
Can you tell me what ice cream maker you use?
Of course. I have a 1.5 quart Cuisinart. Its served me fairly for 10 years until the paddle broke last week. 🙁 it was a sad day.
Awesome recipe! Love the combination of caramel and coffee. One question: how do you stop the caramel from crystalizing? I used a mix of stevia and erythritol, powdered, and after the ice cream was frozen, the caramel became crystall-y. Thanks!
My caramel crystallized a little bit too. I think that is just the nature of sugar alcohols. But I do think xylitol crystallizes less than erythritol.
Every time my caramel cools down it crystallizes how do I get this to stop happening
Are you using gentle sweet?
Do you think coconut milk would sub okay for the heavy cream?
In the ice cream or the caramel? I think coconut cream could possibly work.
I tried the coconut milk and it was just too icy… awesome flavor but really needs heavy cream as called for for the correct consistency. I love your recipes! Thank you for everything you do!!!!
AROY-D is the best coconut milk out there. I think it would make this ice cream work for you. It is creamy and homogenous (unlike the can with a chunk of solids at the top and a watery liquid at the bottom of the can)
I buy 4-6 at a time it on Amazon in litre-sized cartons. I steam it and whip to a foam to add to my coffee.
Good to know! Thanks.
I have beem doing THM for 3 yrs and this is the best dessert I’ve had! I’m going to try the strawberry Recota recipe next. Thank you for sharing your recipes!
“Combine first three ingredients” “add the salt, instant coffee, remaining butter, and remaining cream”
Clarification question: Butter 4Tbsp how much is included in “first three” and how much is “remaining”.
Cream … I “assume” the first is the “1/4 cup” and the remaining is the ” plus 2 tbsp heavy cream”
Sorry if the answer is obvious to others … but I need to know.
And your recipe makes approx 1 quart of ice cream. Can the recipe be multiplied by 4 to be made in a gallon ice cream churn? Thank you for all the HOURS you spend testing recipes so that all of us can have less failures 🙂 … you are so appreciated.
I just edited the recipe box to clarify. And yes, first use the 1/4 cup cream and then add the 2 tbsp later. And I don’t see why you couldn’t multiply by 4 🙂
This looks so good. It’s like all my favorite flavors in one amazing ice cream. Love!!
Wow! I’m not a huge fan of coffee and this still looks amazing!
Thanks! You can always leave out the instant coffee and just make Sweet Cream Caramel 🙂
I adore coffee and caramel flavor together, so I already know this ice cream is going to rock! 🙂
Wow. This sounds delicious. I love the combo of the coffee and caramel. I have often thought to use vegetable glycerine in my ice cream to keep it soft, but have not yet made the jump. I think I’ll try it. Thanks for a great recipe.
This looks absolutely wonderful! Has to be better than store bought stuff.
Wish I wasn’t the only one in the house that likes coffee ice cream.
Moving on to check out your other ice cream recipes. I’m hooked!